Debunking Misconceptions: Athletes with Disabilities Can’t Have Talent

A few days ago I read this story from The Sacramento Bee, “Disabled Student Sues to Play High School Baseball.” The story talks about high school student David Barker suing his high school so he can play junior varsity baseball. According to the article Barker is deaf and has cerebral palsy but has played baseball since he was nine years old, including playing for his school’s freshman baseball team. Yet school officials informed David he couldn’t play at the junior varsity level. The following reader comment from tobeetobee really grabbed my attention and motivated today’s post-

“Yeah right…like every student gets to be on the team because they want to be on it…”

Two other readers liked this comment. Personally the statement disturbs me because the thinking infers athletes with disabilities can’t have talent. To anyone who wants to argue with me I can make a strong case with one name, Jim Abbott. Are you getting ready to ask, “Who is Jim Abbott?” Let me waste no time on educating you. Jim Abbott pitched in the major leagues from 1989 to 1999, compiling a career 87-108 record and 4.25 ERA.   He finished fifth in the AL Rookie of the Year voting in his initial major league season and placed third in the AL Cy Young Award voting during the 1991 season. (Click here for more statistics) Jim Abbott accomplished all this despite being born with a deformed right arm. Rick Swaine describes the deformity on behalf of Society for American Baseball Research (SABR).

“Abbott’s right arm ends about where his wrist should be. He doesn’t have a right hand, just a loose flap of skin at the end of his underdeveloped arm.”

Jim Abbott

Born without a right hand retired MLB pitcher Jim Abbott defied possibilities. Photo: Paul Morse/Wikimedia Commons

Reading Swaine’s SABR biography on Jim Abbott reveals Abbott enjoyed success on every level of baseball he played despite skepticism surfacing Abbott would become outmatched by his competition. A decade in the majors goes to show the skeptics wrong. Now, I’ll admit majority of athletes with disabilities will likely fail to rival Abbott’s talent but the least we can do as a society is give athletes with disabilities the opportunity to fail. So to bring this post full circle, I hope we can judge David Barker by his skills as a baseball player and not the label “disabled athlete.”




One comment on “Debunking Misconceptions: Athletes with Disabilities Can’t Have Talent

  1. Nick Broutin says:

    I went through the same stuff in Highschool, but I ended up wrestling and it changed my life! But I feel for the people with disabilities on this one!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s